The Hindu Explains | Why is there a controversy over a film project on the protagonist of 1921 Malabar Rebellion?

The story up to now: Malayalam film director Aashiq Abu, on June 22, introduced a new film project, Variyamkunnan, on Variyamkunnath Kunhamed Haji, the predominant protagonist of the Malabar Rebellion of 1921 who was executed by the British. Soon, three extra administrators, Ibrahim Vengara, P.T. Kunju Muhammed and Ali Akbar, introduced their very own movies on the similar historic determine. The announcement of Abu, a Left supporter, sparked a controversy, with Sangh Parivar outfits calling on actor Prithviraj Sukumaran, who is enjoying the function of Haji, to not settle for the function in the film, Variyamkunnan. Akbar, a supporter of the Sangh Parivar, has declared that he’ll painting the ‘real face’ of the revolt. A historic occasion that occurred a century in the past suddenly seems to have acquired contemporary relevance.

Why has Aashiq Abu’s film project announcement led to protests?

Unlike in 1988 when the late I.V. Sasi directed 1921, a Malayalam film primarily based on the revolt, political and communal polarisation in Kerala at the moment has led to protests on social media. Amid criticism of Sangh Parivar leaders and assaults in the social media, Prithviraj wrote on his Facebook web page that Haji “stood up against an empire that ruled a quarter of the world”. The Hindu Aikya Vedi introduced a year-long marketing campaign to counter makes an attempt to “glorify” Haji and different leaders who it mentioned have been chargeable for atrocities in opposition to Hindus in southern components of the erstwhile Malabar district of Kerala.

Also learn | Reports of Hindu-Muslim strife in Malabar baseless, wrote Variamkunnath Kunhamed Haji in The Hindu in 1921

Why does the revolt nonetheless stoke passions?

The Malabar Rebellion (additionally known as the Mappila or Moplah Rebellion by the British) broke out in the southern taluks of Malabar in August 1921. By the time the authorities troops captured Haji in January 1922, the revolt had fizzled out. It largely took the form of guerrilla-type assaults on janmis (feudal landlords, who have been largely higher caste Hindus) and the police and troops.

Mappilas had been amongst the victims of oppressive agrarian relations protected by the British. But the political mobilisation of Muslims in the area in the aftermath of the launch of the Khilafat agitation and Gandhi’s non-cooperation battle served as a chance for an extremist part to invoke a spiritual idiom to specific their struggling, whereas working for a change in the oppressive system of administration. There have been excesses on each side — rebels and authorities troops. Incidents of homicide, looting and compelled conversion led many to discredit the rebellion as a manifestation of spiritual bigotry. Moderate Khilafat leaders lamented that the revolt had alienated the Hindu sympathy.

Malabar rebellion | Mission to set the record straight

How did Kunhamed Haji emerge as the chief?

Haji, who was one of the three most essential insurgent leaders, was the face of the revolt. British officers seen him as the “most murderous”. Born in 1866 in a household with relations concerned in a single of the Mappila “outbreaks” or “outrages” in the 19th century, he was aware of the commemoration of shaheeds (martyrs) who fought in opposition to the tyranny of landlords and their helpers, largely higher caste Hindus in the area. There have been a number of such outbreaks in the area throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries. The predominant actors of the outbreaks have been people on suicide missions. The Khilafat motion launched in 1919 offered a recent stimulus to the grievances of Mappilas. Now their sense of native injustice was sought to be linked with the pan-Islamic sentiments created in the aftermath of the collapse of the Ottoman Empire that rendered the Ottoman caliphate irrelevant. Haji was amongst these in the Malabar area impressed by the zeal of the agitation. During the revolt, he led many assaults on people, together with Muslims, who had been loyal to the British. Some modern accounts, nevertheless, deny that he favoured conversion of Hindus.

Also learn | Search begins for 1922 film on Malabar revolt

What was the affect of the protests?

The revolt of Mappilas impressed by spiritual ideology and a conception of an alternate system of administration — a Khilafat authorities — dealt a blow to the nationalist motion in Malabar. The fanaticism of rebels, foregrounded by the British, fostered communal rift and enmity in the direction of the Congress.

Also learn | Variyamkunnan scriptwriter withdraws from film, following controversy

The exaggerated accounts of the revolt engendered a counter marketing campaign in different components of the nation in opposition to ‘fanaticism’ of Muslims. That mentioned, the traumatic expertise of the rebellion additionally persuaded educated sections of the Muslim neighborhood in Malabar to chalk out methods to save lots of the neighborhood from what they noticed as a pathetic scenario. The neighborhood’s stagnation was attributed to spiritual orthodoxy and ignorance. The thrust of the post-rebellion Muslim reform motion in Malabar was a rigorous marketing campaign in opposition to orthodoxy.

You have reached your restrict without cost articles this month.

To get full entry, please subscribe.

Already have an account ? Sign in

Show Less Plan

Subscription Benefits Include

Today’s Paper

Find mobile-friendly model of articles from the day’s newspaper in a single easy-to-read listing.

Faster pages

Move easily between articles as our pages load immediately.

Unlimited Access

Enjoy studying as many articles as you would like with none limitations.


A one-stop-shop for seeing the newest updates, and managing your preferences.

Personalised suggestions

A choose listing of articles that match your pursuits and tastes.


We temporary you on the newest and most essential developments, 3 times a day.

*Our Digital Subscription plans don’t presently embody the e-paper ,crossword, iPhone, iPad cellular functions and print. Our plans improve your studying expertise.

Source link

About The Author